We examine the main reasons, from the curse of Hannah Montana to a lack of creative identity.
Miley Cyrus’ new album, “Bass Persuades,” came out on September 18, but attracted little public interest. It received just 6.2 million streams on Spotify on its first day; many publications did not even review it. Cyrus is a famous figure with an enormous fan base. Yet her releases flop or fall short of major success all too often. Let’s explore why this happens.
The Fame and Curse of Hannah Montana

Photo from Miley Cyrus’ social media
Her role in Hannah Montana (2006–2011) made Miley Cyrus a star. The show was wildly popular. A single episode, “Me and Mr. Jonas and Mr. Jonas and Mr. Jonas,” was watched by more than 10 million people.
The series also partly overlapped with reality. Its main character was also called Miley, although her surname was Stewart, and she was a singer too. An iconic television role is a double-edged sword. On the one hand, it can provide someone with fame and money for life. On the other, the character’s image sticks to them forever.
Whatever Cyrus does, many people will always see her as Hannah Montana. In 2026, a special episode marking the show’s 20th anniversary was released alongside a new song, “Younger You.” It received far more attention than her current album, “Bass Persuades.” Few major publications even bothered to review “Bass Persuades”: only Variety and The Times covered it.
No Defined Musical Style
In theory, variety is wonderful. However, Miley Cyrus swings from one extreme to another far too often. In 2013, eager to shed Hannah Montana’s respectable image, the singer went all in on shock value: twerking at the MTV VMAs, the nude “Wrecking Ball” video, and the party-themed “We Can’t Stop” video with its hints of drug use. Cyrus made headlines everywhere and was accused of debauchery and indecency. In 2015, she decided to provoke the public even further and released the psychedelic album “Miley Cyrus & Her Dead Petz.” The release was available only on SoundCloud (blocked in Russia), so the album itself received little discussion. The video for “BB Talk,” in which Cyrus portrayed a baby, outraged many people, however.
In 2017, the singer became quiet and calm on the gentle country album “Younger Now.” It did not flop, and “Malibu” even reached the Billboard top 10, but the era did not make much noise either. In 2019, Miley Cyrus returned to rebellion with “She Is Coming,” an EP inspired by hip-hop, trap and rock. The public was not especially impressed. Cyrus originally planned a series of three EPs, but her label, RCA, cancelled the follow-ups. To be fair, “Mother’s Daughter” and “Slide Away” found an audience: they have 343 million and 396 million Spotify streams respectively. That same year, Cyrus played the puppet-like pop star Ashley O in Black Mirror (2011–present). She also sang a typical pop song, “On a Roll,” which was… an unusual cover of Nine Inch Nails’ “Head Like a Hole.” The song achieved some popularity: a top-three position on Billboard’s dance chart and 123 million streams. The Black Mirror episode was also widely discussed online.
In 2020, Cyrus turned to rock and released her best work to date, “Plastic Hearts.” She had finally hit the mark. Covers of The Cranberries’ “Zombie” and Metallica’s “Nothing Else Matters” strengthened her rock image. But then the singer veered back into country, synth-pop, dance music… It is difficult to identify Miley Cyrus’ own style.
Plenty of Fans, Few Concerts

Photo from Miley Cyrus’ social media
Miley Cyrus last toured in 2022 in support of “Plastic Hearts.” It was a limited tour: just 11 performances, mostly at festivals such as Lollapalooza and Bottlerock. Her last proper tour was all the way back in 2014, supporting “Bangerz.” Of course, the absence of reasonably regular, full-length shows affects an artist’s career. Live contact with fans is always very important. Miley Cyrus is currently preparing to give two concerts in Los Angeles on October 16 and 18. And perhaps there will be more than two. The singer has hinted that she is considering a residency.
A residency is a series of concerts in one city rather than a tour across different cities. This is more convenient for musicians, since travelling is exhausting. But it is not particularly convenient for fans. Comments on Miley Cyrus’ social media pages point out that she has many fans in Latin America, and far from all of them can afford to travel to the United States. It is not that simple for Americans either: the country is large, and the distances are considerable.
There is enormous demand to see Cyrus perform live: 1.5 million people joined the ticket queue. Yet even more people simply have no way of making the trip. Some of Cyrus’ work was received better outside the United States than at home, including the hits “Nothing Break Like a Heart” and “Midnight Sky,” and “Plastic Hearts” as a whole. “Nothing Break Like a Heart” reached number two in the United Kingdom and topped the charts in Hungary and Croatia. “Plastic Hearts” has three platinum certifications in Brazil and two in Poland, while it still has none in the United States.
Frequent Moves Between Labels
Like all Disney stars, Miley Cyrus initially recorded for the corporation’s label, Hollywood Records. She released three albums there: “Meet Miley Cyrus” (2007), “Breakout” (2009) and “Can’t Be Tamed” (2010). Her desire to leave Hollywood Records is understandable: the label does not develop its artists’ careers, but simply makes money from them.
In 2013, Miley Cyrus released “Bangerz”, featuring “Wrecking Ball” and “We Can’t Stop,” through RCA. In 2021, she moved to Columbia, possibly because RCA had promoted “Plastic Hearts” poorly. This decision is understandable too: there are plenty of unpleasant rumours about RCA neglecting its artists; it is even called a cursed label. Cyrus’ partnership with Columbia initially seemed to work. The single “Flowers” (2023) became her biggest hit in a decade and earned her the first Grammys of her career. The album “Endless Summer Vacation” was generally well received. Its follow-up, “Something Beautiful” (2025), flopped. And then Miley Cyrus… changed labels again, even moving to another corporation. RCA and Columbia belong to Sony Music, while the singer has been working with Atlantic, part of Warner Music, since July 2026.
Any artist is not just an individual, but also a team. The label is part of that team. And if someone frequently changes teams, it affects their image. The public gets a sense of unreliability, as though the artist does not know what they want. Cyrus has not become embroiled in any serious scandals, and she is unlikely to have had major conflicts with label colleagues and producers. Yet her career can hardly be called stable.
No Clear Creative Identity

People online compare Miley Cyrus to Cher. Their stories are indeed similar. Both have spent many years making music, remain household names, have an affinity with rock and have had rather uneven careers. And both have hits, including enormous songs that everybody knows.
Cher began in the folk duo Sonny & Cher and later released all kinds of music. Miley Cyrus has a similarly varied catalogue: country, pop, ballads, dance and rock. But, as already noted, that does not always work in her favour. Even within a single Cyrus era, its central theme and principal style can be difficult to identify. The “Bass Persuades” teaser suggested rock music and was even compared to PJ Harvey’s “This Is Love” video. The involvement of rock band Model/Actriz added to that impression. Then the lead single unexpectedly turned out to be closer to dance-pop in the vein of Lady Gaga. Overall, the new record leans towards dark, slightly experimental pop. Creative identity encompasses everything: style, image and approach; a comprehensive answer to the question, “What does the artist represent, and who are they?”
Miley Cyrus’ stage-name change is another strange situation. Her social media accounts changed from MileyCyrus to simply Miley, yet she is still listed as Cyrus on Spotify. And the singer has a real problem with music videos. Even during the visually focused “Something Beautiful” era in 2025, her videos mostly resembled montages of beautiful shots. “Bass Persuades” is a step forward in that respect: it has a storyline and dancing. But it still falls short of videos by someone such as Gaga.
The Main Question Is Whether Miley Cyrus Herself Wants to Be a Superstar
Miley Cyrus started working at 13, her age during the first season of Hannah Montana. Being a child star is a difficult experience. Still, Cyrus was luckier than some: her father is country singer Billy Ray Cyrus, and the legendary Dolly Parton was her godmother.
Perhaps having connections protected Cyrus from the worst consequences. She seems more stable than Justin Bieber, who is still recovering from childhood fame. But the fact that Cyrus had it a little easier does not mean she had it easy. Her first tour, Best of Both Worlds, began in October 2007, before the young star had even turned 15. It consisted of 71 concerts. A concert tour is always an enormous strain, particularly on a vulnerable teenage psyche. She embarked on her second tour, Wonder World, in 2009, when she was 16. Her third, Gypsy Heart, followed in 2011, when she was 18.
At 33, Miley Cyrus has 20 years of work experience. That is both impressive and rather unsettling when you think about it. There is a reason the singer does not want to tour: she is probably exhausted after so many years of intensive work. Many fans believe that she herself no longer needs hits or sold-out tours. Cyrus was filling her first stadiums at 14. Her first megahit, “Party in the U.S.A.,” came out when she was 16. In effect, enormous fame is a stage she has already been through.
Miley Cyrus has everything she needs to dominate the charts: a famous name, a fan base of millions, experience, industry connections and decent taste. What she lacks is consistency and, apparently, the desire. Taylor Swift went from being a well-known singer to a megastar because she wanted it so much and continues to do everything possible to achieve it. Miley Cyrus, meanwhile, seems more like someone who enjoys releasing music that she herself likes. If the singer suddenly changes her mind and begins pursuing fame specifically, the results could be different.


